âBoyz N the Hoodâ rests in American movie history like a boulder in a riverbed, altering the direction of the stream. After its release in the summer of 1991, everything looked different, including its precursors. âMean Streets,â âRebel Without a Cause,â the Blaxploitation spectacles of the 1970s, the socially conscious crime dramas of the 1930s, classic westerns and samurai epics â somehow John Singleton, a very recent graduate of the University of Southern California film school, synthesized all of those models even as he came up with something bracingly, thrillingly and frighteningly new.
âBoyzâ made him the youngest person â and the first African-American â nominated for a best directing Academy Award. In the annals of cinema, there arenât many first features to match it for ambition and impact (âCitizen Kaneâ? âBreathlessâ?), and its influence on what came after is hard to overstate. Singleton, who died Monday at 51, filled his charactersâ lives with warmth and humor even as they were constantly menaced, and often destroyed, by violence. He infused familiar coming-of-age and gangster-movie tropes with a rare authenticity. This wasnât just a matter of his intimate knowledge of the setting known then as South-Central Los Angeles, but also of his brave, even brazen confidence in himself and his audience.
A blazing debut can be a hard act to follow, and Singletonâs second film, âPoetic Justiceâ (1993), didnât enjoy the same success, at least with critics, as its predecessor. But when I heard the news of Singletonâs passing, âPoetic Justiceâ was the movie I found myself thinking about. Partly because its earnest sentiments â its openheartedness about creativity, love and loss â seemed most apt for mourning an artist who left too soon. Grief, after all, has been part of the filmâs legacy since its male star, Tupac Shakur, was murdered in 1996. And there may be no purer dose of early-â90s nostalgia than watching Shakur and Janet Jackson travel the romantic-comedy arc, their progress from conflict to harmony punctuated by the poems of Maya Angelou and breathtaking vistas of the California countryside.
âPoetic Justiceâ is, in its way, as influential as âBoyz N the Hoodâ and as political as âHigher Learningâ and âRosewood,â Singletonâs subsequent confrontations with past and present-day manifestations of American racism. âPoetic Justiceâ begins with a sly and pointed critique of Hollywood representation. A note tells us weâre in South-Central, but the images are of high-rise, well-heeled Manhattan, where a white couple, played by Billy Zane and Lori Petty, are drinking wine in a penthouse.
The joke is that this is a movie-within-the-movie showing at a Los Angeles drive-in. (The marquee tells us that itâs called âDeadly Divaâ and has an NC-17 rating.) The patrons, including Jacksonâs Justice and her boyfriend (Q-Tip of A Tribe Called Quest), donât look like the people on screen, but theyâve bought tickets anyway, as generations of black and Latinx moviegoers have before them. With a few exceptions, itâs always been that way.
âPoetic Justiceâ sets out to change that situation, by every means available. The stylized, consequence-free gunplay of âDeadly Divaâ is soon drowned out by a shooting that pulls what seemed like an â80s-vintage teen comedy into the brutal world of âBoyz N the Hood.â Within a few minutes, before the opening titles have even scrolled, weâve swerved from satire to sex farce to tragedy, and Singleton is only getting started.
Eventually, Justice and Lucky (Shakurâs character) will set off for Oakland in a Postal Service truck with their friends Iesha (Regina King) and Chicago (Joe Torry), and âPoetic Justiceâ will turn into a road movie. Before their departure, Singleton lingers over the funny and painful details of their lives at home and at work, sketching a portrait of working-class black life that looks back to the radical neorealism of the LA Rebellion and forward to the businesslike striving of the âBarbershopâ franchise. The casting of two stars of popular music as a hairdresser (Jackson) and a mailman (Shakur) doesnât so much glamorize the characters as affirm the realness that the performers had already established as the cornerstone of their appeal.
Between Los Angeles and the Bay Area, the four travelers journey through a kind of utopian space. Not that everything is harmonious among them. Iesha and Chicago have some issues, and Lucky and Justice are barely on speaking terms. Harsh words are exchanged, followed by a few slaps and punches. But the movieâs close attention to this interpersonal friction might cause you to notice what isnât in the picture. There are no police on the highway and almost no white people (except for a belligerent truck driver at a gas station). Justice and company crash a family reunion, where Maya Angelou herself dispenses wisdom and passes judgment on her temporary nieces and nephews. They stop at a cultural festival where revolutionary poets and drummers hold the stage.
This dream evaporates in Oakland, where a shooting has claimed the life of Luckyâs cousin and rap partner. The point of the filmâs long, languorous middle was never to imagine an escape from violence and racism, but to show some of the richness and variety of life in their shadows, to free the characters from the obligation to behave like symbols or avatars of social problems.
Watching âPoetic Justiceâ now, I was put in mind of Barry Jenkinsâ recent âIf Beale Street Could Talk,â and not only because Regina King is (splendidly) in both films. Their visual and storytelling styles are very different, but Jenkins and Singleton are directors whose primary motivation is their unstinting love for the people they conjure into being.
They push aside the noise of plot to capture the quiet intensity of ordinary moments and the poetry of everyday experience. They notice beauty everywhere. âBeale Streetâ and âPoetic Justiceâ are stories of black artists falling in love in a world that tends to devalue both their creativity and their feelings, and each movie simultaneously illuminates those struggles and shares in them, in a spirit that is sorrowful but never grim or despairing.
My point isnât to establish a lineage, but to identify a common spirit, and to measure the shape and size of the doorway that Singleton made, an opening wide enough for so many others to walk through.
This article originally appeared in The New York Times.