Trial of man who helped immigrants at the border ends in a hung jury

Increasingly, these kinds of efforts have landed people in jail. In 2017, a summer that saw a brutal heat wave, several volunteers with the group No More Deaths were arrested on federal misdemeanor charges for placing water in a federally protected wilderness area. The stakes were raised significantly in 2018, when Border Patrol agents set up surveillance near one of the humanitarian bases and filed three felony charges against Scott Warren, a 36-year-old geography teacher who helped a pair of migrants from Central America who had arrived there hungry, dehydrated and with blistered feet.

Warren’s case resulted in a mistrial Tuesday, after jurors said for a second day that they were unable to reach a verdict. Judge Raner C. Collins of U.S. District Court in Tucson set a conference for July 2 to discuss how to proceed.

The trial had drawn worldwide attention and spurred 30 vigils across the United States, a reflection of the fraught debate over immigration issues since President Donald Trump made border security a central issue of his administration.

Key to the case was Warren’s intent: Was he wholly motivated by a humanitarian purpose when he gave food, water, shelter and clean clothes to the two men from Central America? Or was he illegally concealing the men when he allowed them to remain at the volunteer group’s camp?

Jurors had announced Monday that they were deadlocked, but they resumed deliberations Tuesday after the judge ordered them to try again — one sign of the difficult questions raised by the case.

“Scott Warren remains innocent, both as a legal matter and as a factual matter, because the jury could not unanimously conclude otherwise,” the lead defense lawyer, Gregory Kuykendall, said after the jury was dismissed. “The government put on its best case with the full force of countless resources, and 12 jurors could not agree with that case.”

Warren read a brief statement. “In the time since I was arrested in January 2018, no fewer than 88 bodies were recovered from the Arizona desert,” he said. “The government’s plan in the midst of this humanitarian crisis? Policies to target undocumented people, refugees and their families. Prosecutions to criminalize humanitarian aid, kindness and solidarity.”

Prosecutors made no comment after the jury was dismissed.

From the beginning, defense lawyers contended that the case was part of the government’s escalating security strategy on the southwest border.

“Threatening humanitarians with felonies and prison time for helping migrants survive in the desert is part of the Trump strategy to deter immigration. This case is a test of that,” Kuykendall said in an interview.

Kuykendall argued in court that Warren had not committed a crime by helping the migrants, even if what he did might have allowed them to stay out of sight of law enforcement agents. “Scott Warren is a law-abiding, life-giving good Samaritan,” he told the jury.

But federal prosecutors said the real issue was whether Warren went much further than helping save the men’s lives. “This case is not about humanitarian aid, or anyone in medical distress,” said Nathaniel Walters, one of the prosecutors. The issue the jury was asked to decide, he told the court, was whether Warren attempted to “shield” two unauthorized immigrants from law enforcement for several days.

Warren was charged with one count of conspiracy to transport unauthorized immigrants, which carries a 10-year sentence, and two counts of harboring them. His trial, which began May 29, was widely seen as a test of the legal limits for providing humanitarian aid to migrants who are otherwise subject to arrest.

U.N. human rights officials called for charges in the case to be dropped, noting that Arizona has some of the border’s deadliest migrant corridors, accounting for over a third of the more than 7,000 border deaths recorded over the last two decades. Temperatures in the Sonoran desert can reach 120 degrees in summer and fall below freezing in winter.

“Humanitarian aid is not a crime,” the U.N. Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights said in a statement.

Warren was indicted after Trump’s first attorney general, Jeff Sessions, directed federal prosecutors to prioritize cases involving the harboring of unauthorized immigrants. In the past, the anti-harboring law has been used mainly against smugglers who transport migrants for profit, and occasionally against employers who knowingly recruit workers living in the country illegally.

The trial of Warren was marked with protests outside the courthouse and other shows of support for him and his group. Faith leaders, health workers, educators and community members filled the courtroom. About 125,000 people signed an online petition demanding that the case be dismissed.

Warren’s defense lawyers said their client was targeted by the Justice Department because No More Deaths had distributed a video showing Border Patrol agents destroying jugs of water that the group had placed in the desert. Warren was arrested a few hours after the video was posted online. A spokesman for Customs and Border Protection, Robert Daniels, said the agency could not comment during the pending prosecution.

Border Patrol agents arrested Warren and the two migrants — Kristian Perez Villanueva, from El Salvador, and Jose Sacaria Goday, from Honduras — on Jan. 17, 2018, at a house called the Barn, about 110 miles from Tucson. The site serves as a base camp for No More Deaths; the group’s volunteers congregate there, store provisions in its shed and set out from there to search the desert for migrants’ remains.

Perez said in a videotaped deposition that he and Sacaria had crossed the border near the Mexican town of Sonoyta with some other men by climbing a fence. On Jan. 17, he said, after walking for eight hours, guided through the desert by a compass and the stars, the two men reached a gas station, where a man offered to drive them to a place to rest. That place was the Barn, located in Ajo, a town of about 3,000 people some 32 miles north of the border.

That driver was identified by prosecutors and a Border Patrol agent as Irineo Mujica, a Mexican American with dual citizenship who is a leader of the Pueblo Sin Fronteras, a group that has organized caravans from Central America to the United States and operates a shelter on the Mexican side of the border. He was arrested by Mexican authorities last week.

The migrants found no one at the Barn but managed to gain access to a bathroom on the property, according to Sacaria. When Warren arrived about 40 minutes later, he said, “We just asked him to let us rest for a few days, one or two days, that we were going to leave.”

Warren’s lawyer, Kuykendall, said the activist was surprised to find the men at the Barn. After asking them a few questions, he said, Warren began to follow the No More Deaths group’s protocol, which among other things called for screening the men for ailments and providing them with sustenance.

“Scott intended one thing, to provide basic human kindness in the form of humanitarian aid,” Kuykendall said in court.

But federal prosecutors said Warren conspired to transport the migrants and shield them from Border Patrol agents, who testified that they saw him giving the men directions that would help them avoid a checkpoint.

“I was watching the defendant pointing to the north and moving his hand around to different landmarks to the north of the Barn, and I watched the two Hispanic males that were with them just kind of following around where he was looking,” Brendan Burns, one of the agents, told the court.

Burns said he and his partner, John Marquez, had taken turns observing the men from a distance using a tripod-mounted “spotting scope” and a set of binoculars.

In his testimony, Warren said he was helping the migrants orient themselves in their surroundings to “self-rescue,” part of the No More Deaths protocol.

During cross-examination, Border Patrol agents said they knew Warren would be in the area when they decided to conduct surveillance of the house, and they moved in to arrest him when they saw him with the two men.

Collins, who was appointed by President Bill Clinton in 1998, rejected a pretrial motion by the defense to dismiss the case on the grounds that Warren’s arrest amounted to selective enforcement in violation of the Fifth Amendment.

As border security has been tightened near legal crossings, migrants have increasingly been taking routes through remote, desolate stretches of desert. More than 3,000 migrants have died in the Arizona desert since 2000.

At least eight other volunteers from No More Deaths have been prosecuted this year in connection with the group’s activities in aid of migrants. Four were convicted on misdemeanor charges and were sentenced to fines and probation; another four pleaded guilty to violating regulations in the Cabeza Prieta National Wildlife Refuge and were fined.

Warren also faces misdemeanor charges for driving a truck on a road in the wildlife area. Collins has not ruled on that case.

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.